Why is the cash offer on my house below market value, and should I take it?
A cash offer can come in below market value because a quick sale, by an owner who cannot fix the house first, is a different kind of deal. It can be worth taking when speed, the state of the house or your situation counts for more than price; compare what you would keep, not the two prices. This guide draws on the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and the Appraisal Subcommittee (ASC).
Last reviewed
Clear Cash for Homes does not buy houses and is not a broker or agent; local cash buyers in our network make the offers. How it works
Is a cash offer below market value normal?
It can be. Cash offers can come in under what the same house could bring on the open market once it is repaired. A low offer is still only an offer: you can ask questions, push back or say no.
An appraisal and an automated valuation, side by side
| What is compared | An appraisal | An automated valuation |
|---|---|---|
| Who or what makes it | A licensed real estate appraiser. Source: consumerfinance.gov | A computer, using mathematical models. Source: consumerfinance.gov |
| What it is based on | A full inspection of the property, with adjustments between the home's features and comparable local sales, called comps. Source: consumerfinance.gov | Details of the home, such as bedrooms, bathrooms and square feet, compared with recent sales and other information about the local housing market. Source: consumerfinance.gov |
| What you get | A written document that shows an opinion of how much the property is worth and describes what makes it valuable. Source: consumerfinance.gov | A computer-generated value. Source: consumerfinance.gov |
| How lenders use it | The most common type of valuation; a lender may require a full appraisal by a licensed appraiser. Source: consumerfinance.gov | A lender may get one when you first apply for a loan, to check that the property value is reasonable. Source: consumerfinance.gov |
Why do cash buyers offer less than market value?
Market value is a price for a particular kind of sale. A quick sale, by an owner who needs to be done or cannot fix the house first, is a different kind of deal.
Some cash buyers plan to repair the house and then resell or rent it.
How can you tell if a cash offer is too low for you?
Compare what you would keep, not the two prices.
Get your own numbers for the parts you can check: a repair quote from a contractor, an agent's opinion of the likely list price, and the payoff amount from your mortgage company.
What can you do about a low cash offer?
You have more choices than yes or no.
Say no.
Counter it.
List the house.
Fix a few things first.
Keep it for now.
Questions people ask
Can you legally sell a house for less than market value?
Yes, as a rule. No federal rule we read sets a minimum price for selling your own home.
What happens if I sell my house for less than it is worth?
You keep less from the sale, and if the price still clears your mortgage, that is the main cost.
Can I sell my house to my son or daughter below market value?
Yes, but the IRS may treat part of it as a gift, since it counts any transfer as a gift when full value is not received in return.
Is a low offer from an unrelated cash buyer a gift for tax purposes?
Generally not. A Treasury regulation treats a genuine sale made at arm's length in the ordinary course of business, with no intent to give anything away, as a sale for full value.
Do I pay tax if I sell my house below market value?
If the house was your main home and you meet the IRS ownership and use tests, you may be able to leave part or all of your gain out of your income.
Is an automated home value the same as an appraisal?
No. The CFPB calls an automated valuation a computer-generated value from mathematical models.
How do I check that an appraiser is licensed?
Search the Appraiser Registry on the ASC's site by name, city or state.
Can you negotiate a cash offer on a house?
Yes. When a buyer makes an offer, you can say yes, say no, ask questions or ask for more time, and you can name your own figure with your reasons.
Should I take a lowball cash offer?
It can be worth taking when what it saves you matters more to you than the money it costs: for example, when speed, the state of the house or your own situation counts for more than price.
General information, not legal, tax or financial advice.
Rules in your state
Rules for contract assigners, state by state
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming
More guides
- How a cash offer on a house works, with the pros and cons
- How to check a cash buyer is real
- House needs work
- FSBO vs Realtor: should I sell my house myself or with an agent?
- Rent vs sell: should I sell my house or rent it out?
- Short sale vs foreclosure: what is the difference?
- My cash buyer stopped answering after I signed. Can I back out before closing?
- Can Medicaid or a nursing home take your house?
- Why do I keep getting offers to buy my house, and how do I make them stop?
- What happens with the home inspection when you sell your house?
- Facing foreclosure
- Parent moving to senior living
- Offerpad alternatives: Clear Cash for Homes, which connects you with local cash buyers and charges you nothing, and other ways to sell
- What is a real estate wholesaler?
- House not selling? Your options when it sits on the market
Get an offer on your house
Sources: Internal Revenue Service; Electronic Code of Federal Regulations; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau; Appraisal Subcommittee of the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council; Social Security Administration.