Rent vs sell: should I sell my house or rent it out?
No single rule decides whether to sell your house or rent it out. Selling turns the house into money at closing and ends your costs of owning it; renting it out keeps the house and adds rent, along with a landlord's work, more tax forms and legal duties to your tenants. This guide compares the two from what the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) publish.
Last reviewed
Clear Cash for Homes does not buy houses and is not a broker or agent; local cash buyers in our network make the offers. How it works
Should I sell my house or rent it out?
No single rule decides it. Selling turns the house into money at closing and ends your costs of owning it. Renting it out keeps the house and adds rent, along with a landlord's work, more tax forms and legal duties to your tenants.
Renting the house out and selling it, side by side
| What is compared | Rent it out | Sell it |
|---|---|---|
| Money coming in | Rent from a tenant. Source: irs.gov | The sale price, paid at closing. |
| Income tax | Rent is taxable income. Source: irs.gov | If it was your main home and you meet the ownership and use tests, you may exclude up to $250,000 of your gain from income, or up to $500,000 if you file a joint return with your spouse. Source: irs.gov |
| The home sale tax exclusion | Possible if you owned and lived in the home at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale. Source: irs.gov | Generally available if you owned the home and lived in it for at least 2 of the 5 years before the sale, and did not exclude the gain on another home sold in the 2 years before. Source: irs.gov |
What changes if you rent it out
You become a landlord. You, or a property manager you pay, find tenants, collect the rent and handle repairs. The mortgage, insurance and property taxes stay yours, even in months when the house sits empty.
The IRS counts rent as taxable income.
What changes if you sell it
A sale ends your part in the house. You are paid at closing, through a neutral closing agent that handles the money and the paperwork, often a title company, an escrow company or a real estate attorney, depending on the state.
Questions to ask yourself before you decide
Do your mortgage and your insurance policy allow you to rent the house out? Would the rent leave something over for the months between tenants? Do you need the money from a sale for your next home?
Questions people ask
Does it ever make sense to sell your house and rent?
It can. It depends on your plans and costs, not on any one rule.
Is rent from my old house taxable?
Yes. The IRS treats rent as taxable income, and also money a tenant pays to cancel a lease and expenses a tenant pays for you.
If I rent my house out now, can I still get the home sale tax exclusion later?
Possibly. An IRS example is an owner who moved out, rented the house and then sold it while more than two of the years lived there still fell within the five years before the sale.
General information, not legal, tax or financial advice.
More guides
- How to buy a house and sell yours at the same time
- Tenants in place
- Inherited house
- Vacant house
- How a cash offer on a house works, with the pros and cons
- Sell my house fast near me: our network buys houses for cash, state by state
- FSBO vs Realtor: should I sell my house myself or with an agent?
- Listing agent vs selling agent: what is the difference?
- Selling a house in probate: can you sell it, and how does it work?
- Do you pay capital gains tax on an inherited house?
- Do you pay capital gains tax when you sell your house?
- What are the closing costs to sell a house, and who pays them?
- When is the best time to sell a house?
- House not selling? Your options when it sits on the market
Get an offer on your house
Sources: Internal Revenue Service; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency; U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.