Short sale vs deed in lieu of foreclosure: what is the difference?

In a short sale, you sell the home to a buyer for less than you owe, with your lender's or servicer's agreement. In a deed in lieu of foreclosure, there is no buyer: you hand ownership over to the lender in place of foreclosure. With either, depending on your state, you may still owe the deficiency, the gap between the home's value and what you owe, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (the federal consumer bureau) says.

Last reviewed

Thinking of selling for cash?

Start here with the first question. If qualified, someone from our network will call you, typically within 24 hours. We charge you nothing. You are under no obligation to accept any offer.

How soon do you want to sell?

Clear Cash for Homes does not buy houses and is not a broker or agent; local cash buyers in our network make the offers. How it works

What is the difference between a short sale and a deed in lieu of foreclosure?

In a short sale, you sell the home to a buyer for less than you owe on the mortgage, and your lender or servicer agrees to accept that price. In a deed in lieu of foreclosure there is no buyer: you voluntarily hand ownership of the home over to the lender, in place of the foreclosure process.

Short sale and deed in lieu of foreclosure, side by side

What is compared Short sale Deed in lieu of foreclosure
Who ends up with the house A buyer, at a price your lender or servicer agrees to accept, even if it is less than you owe. Source: consumerfinance.gov The lender. Source: selling-guide.fanniemae.com
Moving out The bureau notes that because it is a sale, you will have to move out of the home. Source: consumerfinance.gov For a loan Fannie Mae owns, the servicer must tell you of three exits: move at once, stay 3 months with no rent, or take a 12-month lease at market rent. Source: servicing-guide.fanniemae.com
Money still owed afterward Depending on your state, you may be responsible for the deficiency, the gap between the property's value and what you still owe, and the lender could sue for it. Source: consumerfinance.gov If your state makes you responsible for a deficiency, you can ask the lender to waive it. Source: consumerfinance.gov

What a short sale asks of you

A short sale cannot close until your lender or servicer agrees to a price below what you owe, and until it closes the house is still yours.

What a deed in lieu asks of you

A deed in lieu does not wait on a buyer, but the lender has to accept the house.

What can either one still cost you?

For a loan Fannie Mae owns with no mortgage insurance, or whose insurer gave Fannie Mae authority, the servicer must release you from any deficiency once the short sale or deed in lieu is complete. Otherwise, what you may owe afterward depends on your state and on what your lender agrees to. The bureau's advice is the same for both: where your state makes you responsible for a deficiency, ask the lender to waive it, and keep the waiver in writing.

Questions people ask

Is a deed in lieu better than a short sale?

Neither is better for every homeowner.

How long does a deed in lieu of foreclosure stay on your credit?

No federal page we read gives a separate time for a deed in lieu or a short sale; the CFPB says a credit reporting company generally can report most negative information for seven years.

How long does a deed in lieu of foreclosure take?

No single length applies to every loan.

What happens when you do a deed in lieu of foreclosure?

You sign ownership of the house over to the lender instead of going through a foreclosure.

Can I give my house back to the bank?

Only if the lender agrees.

How do you ask for a deed in lieu of foreclosure?

Contact your servicer, the company that collects your payments, and ask which options to avoid foreclosure it offers on your loan.

Does a deed in lieu affect a VA home loan benefit?

It can. The VA says a deed in lieu, like a short sale, could result in a loss or reduction in your future home loan benefit.

Is there a deed in lieu of foreclosure form?

For a loan Freddie Mac owns, yes: Freddie Mac's mortgage assistance application, which you send to your servicer, lists transferring ownership of the property to your servicer as one of the things you can ask for.

General information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

More guides

Get an offer on your house

Get an offer How to check a cash buyer

Sources: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau; Internal Revenue Service; Fannie Mae; U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development; U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs; Freddie Mac.

Get an offer